Issues for known creators

Good evening, I’m Sam.

I’ve been involved in the FiveM scene for a while. Generally, I prefer to keep to myself and avoid causing disagreements or problems for anyone. However, recently there have been some matters that I believe need to be clarified.

Through this post, I want to encourage known developers, mappers, and creators to share their opinions on a few topics. It would be wonderful to receive constructive feedback from FiveM admins and developers.

Errors in the Escrow System

I am a fan of the escrow system. It’s great to have a feature that protects us creators from leaks and resellers. Certainly, it’s not perfect - no system can be - but there are some issues that I believe every creator has noticed.

The system is generating numerous errors and causing problems for those who purchase escrow-protected resources, such as Error parsing script and Failed to verify protected resource. Frequently, these errors occur when software like Filezilla is used to upload files, which in turn corrupts binary files. However, sometimes it’s virtually impossible to identify the cause of these errors. This results in a large volume of support requests where people blame the asset and its creator. It would be beneficial to find a solution that doesn’t result in the asset’s creator receiving insults and being dragged into unnecessary (and impolite) debates.

Revocation of Tebex Assets

It’s common knowledge that the revoke button has recently been removed from Tebex. I agree that assets should NOT be revocable without cause. But with the new Tebex policies, it appears that it’s now impossible to revoke assets from anyone, even resellers. This becomes a problem when there’s compelling evidence of individuals reselling their entire FiveM accounts, along with all their assets (or just a few), or openly stating that they need support for something they purchased from third-party resellers and was transferred to them.

Tebex’s response to reselling essentially implies that unless there is evidence of the transaction, they won’t take any action. For instance, I attached a screenshot of a person admitting that they had purchased an asset from another individual, but Tebex claimed they could not take any action as there was no proof of payment (despite the person’s self-admission).

This is one of the proofs that in my opinion was more than enough

And this was part of the answer

Recap

  • It would be beneficial to have solutions for escrow errors that don’t lead to increased support requests for creators, as these are not caused by the asset itself, but by external factors.
  • It would be useful to reinstate the revoke button for verified creators, with compulsory proof of inappropriate behavior.

It would be appreciated if other creators could bring up any other important matters for discussion. Let’s keep the conversation organized and respectful. We all know that FiveM admins are extremely busy, and the time you dedicate to me/us is greatly appreciated.

23 Likes

Completely agree with you!

To add to this post, if the problem is that creators abuse this “revoke” button, make a system of verified stores and they can use it or something similar.

9 Likes

Capy here u are right but otherwise in my country almost every server i see is using account like on acount purchase resources and three servers using it and paying monthly 15 to 30$ that is not good for creator like jaksam and others and due to these reason i stop writing script even i have good knowledge but i don’t want to waste my time for that type of communtiy which don’t care for anything and even if we have proof like jaksam says still we cannot do anything here

4 Likes

I very much agree with Sam, we should be more listened to by the community, since more than once I have seen posts of my free scripts here on the forum, or even people saying that they are going to replicate and publish them for free.

The worst thing is when the older customers start to see that their valuable exclusive scripts are being posted for free or replicated in the same forum, that causes me a lot of problems in my tickets for example.

There are too many good things that FiveM provides us, but we need a little more protection, since some of us are former sellers and I think it is not fair that we have to deal with resellers, free reposters, etc. All this within the community where we work.

I consider myself a fan of escrow and I’m happy with it, beyond the problems with FilleZilla which, it is true, causes a lot of tickets, but I think that in general, we should have more protection in our work environment.

About Tebex, a system of verified stores would be great where we can protect ourselves against resellers by revoking assets with a viable description, or perhaps allow us to put information on the case and judge whether to revoke or not, since sending emails for each reseller, in my case, I should send a lot, since my assets are resold all the time.

Thanks for reading, props to Sam and the other creators! :smile:

12 Likes

I appreciate Quasar’s post and fully agree with his perspective. It’s disheartening to witness our free and paid scripts being shared without permission or proper credit within the community. As creators, we deserve to be heard and respected.

I share the belief that FiveM provides us with many valuable features, but it’s crucial to have stronger protection for our work. Dealing with resellers and individuals who repost our content for free can be frustrating, particularly for those of us who have previously sold our assets. We should be able to work in an environment that values and supports the original creators.

Regarding Tebex, I agree that a system of verified stores would be an excellent solution.

6 Likes

Revoke Button Removal :
I fully agree with this I find it totally senseless that the “revoke” button was removed there are partly people who sell their keymaster scripts in a big way and we can’t do anything about it. example the image i send below

Escrow :
The Escrow system is a very good system in my opinion but I think it’s just a pity that it’s only for LUA I would like to write scripts with JS but there are not many good encryption methods for javascript I would be very happy for the future if JS is adopted in escrow.

Forum :
i just can’t understand that free scripts always have to be opensource. i mean what do we have the escrow system for ? to protect our scripts of course but why can’t we do that with free scripts (i’m talking about not being allowed to upload them to the forum)

8 Likes

totaly on your side! 100%

3 Likes

I agree too

3 Likes

Totally approved! I work with quasar, and I see a lot of users reselling their asset, and it’s killing all the shop. A Store Approval System Can Be Cool

3 Likes

I completely agree. They should do some applications to be verified on tebex so we can revoke assets.
We had some partnerships with rp servers, they stopped showing our ad so we decided to revoke their assets that we gave to them for free, but we cannot. We contacted cfx support but no response, even after a month

3 Likes

I totally agree with you.

My solution is simple, make Tebex a Verified program, when the store will be verified, it will have open new features, one of the essential features would be the “revoke button” which will allow to cancel the license of the person in question for an indefinite period of time, when removing the license it will always be necessary to give a reason.

It has happened several times that someone has contacted us and then it was found out that they are using for example a shared keymaster account, or they have got the license from someone else who has resold it to them. Also, since there is no longer a “revoke feature” I believe a lot of creators have a problem when someone contacts them and says their account was stolen or something along those lines, and the creator has no way to help them.

I think this problem should be addressed, and it will save a lot of time for the creators, and there will be an opportunity to help the customers as well.

Kanikuly
Founder and Lead Programmer of RTX Development team.

5 Likes

I agree with RTX, a verified system would be incredible, that would help players buy in a secure store and feel safe. So they will know when the store is trustworthy and safe.

The verified system would be an incredible idea really.

3 Likes

The issue on this is, in this system smaller developers will not have the ability and chances to become verified if it requires a certain amount of users or knowing

3 Likes

It’s just that if you don’t know about scripts and you see a store that sells a really nice script, you don’t know if the script is a reseller or if it’s really theirs, and it happens so many times that it’s frustrating…

2 Likes

youre absolutely correct. I agree what you mean and the idea isnt bad at all. They just need to think it out correctly ofcourse and if they do im pretty sure we could have a nice and good working system

2 Likes

I would just do some sort of id verification or have like 500 purchases on tebex to become verified

3 Likes

I think ID verifications should be a normal thing when selling online tbh, I agree on such a system. Hopefully Tebex and CFX will find a solution

5 Likes

Well that’s true, this is very important, since Tebex does not know who is doing copyright infringement, it could be an anonymous person who put a random name.

3 Likes

Youre 100% right, they should do such a thing

1 Like

I agree with this too!

2 Likes